• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Curious, Healing

Curious, Healing

Books about healing, business, and fun

  • About Sonia Connolly

“Crucial Conversations Third Edition” by Patterson, Grenny, McMillan

September 4, 2022 by Sonia Connolly Leave a Comment

book cover

Subtitle: Tools For Talking When Stakes Are High

Recommended to me by: my boss

I read this book back in 2013 and decided to reread it when my boss mentioned it.

In addition to my summary in 2013, I noticed more about questioning inner stories. When we assign roles like Villain, Victim, and Helpless One, we close off avenues to potential solutions. When we can see everyone in a situation as a complex human with a mix of skills, past experiences, and motivations, we can see openings for solutions more clearly.

I wrote about a similar approach in 2018 in Offer a Collaborative Story.

Crucial Conversations has an oversimplified approach to emotions. The claim is that emotions are caused by our stories, and we have to change stories to change or quiet our emotions. While it is true that a negative story can escalate negative emotions, overall our emotions are signals about our inner truth. It is a mark of privilege to expect everyone to be calm in a difficult situation. Telling people they are causing a problem by having the “wrong story” can quickly shade into gaslighting.

The book has an extended example where a woman is silenced and talked over by a man in a business context. The message of the example is that we have to give everyone the benefit of the doubt and ask them for what we need without regard to privilege, sexism, and institutional power. We all exist in a sexist, racist, capitalist system, and people who act out those biases are not inherently evil. At the same time, putting responsibility on a less privileged individual to manage the situation without mentioning the systemic issues in play is oversimplified and imbalanced. The authors could have mentioned that the situation is stacked against the less privileged person, and that if their techniques don’t work, it doesn’t mean she did them wrong or didn’t try hard enough.

The book contains a lot of ableist and judgmental language. “Dumb” and other slurs are used liberally. Some behaviors are ascribed to “the worst at dialogue” (italics theirs) without noticing that they are failing at their own command to be generous and ascribe positive motives.

This is a recently published third edition. While it contains some useful ideas, I cannot recommend it wholeheartedly because of the shortcomings that have not been addressed.

Available at Powell’s Books.

Filed Under: nonfiction Tagged With: business, communication, psychology, relationship

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Books

  • “Six Reasons to Travel” by Stuart Gelzer
  • “Unmasking Autism” by Devon Price, PhD
  • “Ask for Horses” by Tina Tau
  • “Refactoring” by Martin Fowler
  • “Flying Solo” by Linda Holmes
  • “Thanks for the Feedback” by Douglas Stone & Sheila Heen
  • “Tales From Moominvalley” by Tove Jansson
  • “Crucial Conversations Third Edition” by Patterson, Grenny, McMillan
  • “The Changeling Sea” by Patricia McKillip
  • “The Manager’s Path” by Camille Fournier

Tags

activism aging anti-racism bodywork business childhood abuse childrens communication disability domestic violence feminism finance Focusing food fun healing health at any size illustrated lgbt marketing memoir natural world neurodiversity politics psychology relationship science singing software spirituality survival story trauma writing young adult

Categories

Archives

Please note: Amazon and Powell's links are affiliate links. Copyright © 2023 · Genesis Sample on · WordPress